Atheists and agnostics elaborate on their opposition to abortion. See the full “Ask An Atheist” interview series here. Atheists and agnostics opposed to abortion can submit their own interview answers here.

Every interview in this series starts with one person willing to speak up. Are you a pro-life atheist or agnostic? You could be next. Take our interview survey to get started. Not sure how to tell your story yet? Our free, self-paced Storytelling Symposium can help.

If you appreciate our work and would like to help, one of the most effective ways to do so is to become a monthly donor. You can also give a one time donation here or volunteer with us here.

Click here to add your own text

Click here to add your own text

Three keys to fetal pain – Part 3: The irrelevance of cortical necessity

The way I see it, there are three keys to fetal pain. These keys apply to pain experts, since the rest of us instinctively recognize and may even feel the pain of other living beings.

The first key was the definition of pain, which the IASP revised in 2020 to include pain in animals and nonverbal humans. The second key was 4D ultrasound evidence of fetal pain behaviors.

This time, I’ll examine key #3—the clinical irrelevance and decreasing academic stature of cortical necessity.

What cortical necessity means

“Cortical necessity” is my term for the idea that a mature, connected cerebral cortex is necessary for consciousness in general and pain in particular.

From Latin, meaning “bark,” the cortex is the convoluted outer 2-4 millimeters of the brain. It’s the last part of the brain to mature, developing into the mid-20s and even late-30s.

Cortical necessity is a powerful idea – indeed, it is the crux of the academic debate on fetal pain – but it’s more of an axiom than a falsifiable scientific theory. The philosophy crystallized in this axiom guides the focus of fetal pain research, whether it is done on living or dead fetuses.

Pro-choice organizations focus on the dead

Pro-choice medical organizations prioritize research performed on dead fetuses. The cortex can be identified histologically around 8 weeks’ gestational age (GA). But because these organizations believe a mature, connected cortex is necessary for pain, and because neurons connecting the cortex to the thalamus are not in place before 24 weeks, they assert that fetal consciousness and pain are not possible before what I call a supposed “consciousness barrier” of at least 24 weeks—or perhaps 28 weeks, “29 to 30 weeks, based on the limited data available,” “late in the third trimester,” or even “approximately 12 months of age.”  There’s not a lot of consensus.

NICU specialists focus on the living

By contrast, clinicians in neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) treat living babies for signs of pain even at 22 weeks, well before the “consciousness barrier.” They offer this care without regard to the cortical status of their tiny patients.

During fetal surgery, clinicians treat pain even earlier. As Thill (2023) notes,

Fetal surgeons administer direct fetal analgesia and anesthesia as early as 15–16 weeks gestation (7, 8). Fetal anesthesiologists recommend the use of fetal anesthesia from the second trimester onward (>14 weeks gestation) (9), or in all invasive maternal-fetal procedures regardless of gestational age, in order to “inhibit the humoral stress response, decrease fetal movement, and blunt any perception of pain” [(10), p. 1167]

The Society of Maternal-Fetal Medicine (2021) suggests that the onset of fetal pain capacity is no earlier than 24-25 weeks to the “early third trimester”—presumably weeks 27 to 33—due to “lack of functional connections between cortical structures.”

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (2022) mirrors SMFM’s broad timeline, suggesting pain can arise no earlier than 24-25 weeks, when brain “connections and structures” are present, but possibly “third trimester at the earliest” (27 or 28 weeks until 40 weeks), or perhaps “late in the third trimester” (presumably 34 weeks or later) when “neural circuitry necessary to distinguish touch from painful touch” supposedly develops.

The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (2022) proposes the narrowest window for the onset of fetal pain capacity: 28 weeks, when “key features of the functional connectome” are present, or perhaps 30-31 weeks with “a shift from endogenous neuronal activity to sensory-driven cortical patterns” occurs.

To put it bluntly, cortical necessity is clinically irrelevant.

More evidence against cortical necessity

Cortical necessity also seems to be factually wrong. Several studies have inadvertently called the concept into question. One from 2016 showed cortical activity on brain imaging without pain; another showed increased pain in a man without the supposed pain centers of his brain, with no demonstrated cortical activity at all.

In other words, the cortex serves to modulate or dampen pain, not enable it.

Despite the objections of the two pro-choice authors of these studies, their combined research is a classic example of double dissociation, a neuroscientific research method comparing two patients with opposite symptoms. One loses function A but keeps function B, and the other loses function B but keeps function A. Here, functions A and B are pain experience and cortical activity. The researchers seem to have neatly separated the two.

Likewise, Swedish neuroscientist Bjorn Merker found that hydranencephalic children—children born without cerebral cortexes—show personality, preferences, and sensitivity to pain.

“The tacit consensus concerning the cerebral cortex as the ‘organ of consciousness,’” he concluded, “may in fact be seriously in error.”

Life without a cortex

No one wants to live life without a cortex, but it appears to be possible. In fact, the brain is so redundant that even with minimal or no cortexes, animals can lead functional lives and appear normal to observers.

“Brain of a white collar worker” – Lancet (2007)

Studies of humans have revealed much the same, provoking brain researchers to ask, “Is the cortex necessary?” and “Is a cerebral cortex even necessary to instantiate an experience of pain?”

Not just functioning but high-functioning individuals have been found lacking up to 95% of their brains, leading Science News Editor Roger Lewin to ask in exasperation, “Is your brain really necessary?”

Noting some of the evidence above, one eminent pediatric anesthesiologist asked, in his testimony before Congress: “If cortical activity is not required for pain perception in adults, why should it be a necessary criterion for fetuses?”

Indeed. And because the fetus from 20 to 32 weeks’ gestation has a higher density of pain receptors per square inch than she will have at any point in her life – at the same time her brain has not yet developed pain-dampening neurons – she may feel pain more intensely than at any point in her life.

From “Facial expressions of acute pain in 23-week fetus” (Bernardes and colleagues, 2021)

Responding to Objections

Cortical necessity adherents generally advance two objections. Each one reveals the weakness of the case for cortical necessity.

Objection 1: “You are conflating nociceptive reflex with pain.”

Measurable distress clusters–vital sign spikes, stress hormones, and withdrawal and facial movements, in context of injury–are merely “subcortical reflex arcs” (nociception), which lack a conscious, emotional counterpart (pain)

But the logic doesn’t hold, and it’s circular.

  • Adults have nociceptive reflexes and pain; reflexes do not rule out consciousness. 
  • Reflex is assumed because the cortex isn’t mature; the cortex isn’t mature, so all response is assumed to be reflex. But this is axiomatic; definitional. Semantics, not science.
  • Part 2 addresses this head-on, quoting Castiello and colleagues (2010): “Reflexes are not goal directed, are not subject to learning and do not adjust to future states in a prospective fashion.” All of these were found in their study of 14-week fetuses.

A good question to release the definitional deadlock of cortical necessity: “What evidence would convince you otherwise?”

Objection 2: “Adult anomalies rely on neuroplasticity that a fetus hasn’t developed.”

Critics will claim that hydranencephalic children or adults missing 95% of their brain mass can function only because of “neuroplasticity:” their brains had years of postpartum stimuli to slowly re-wire alternate pathways. A 16-week fetus, they claim, has not had enough time or stimuli.

But this backfires:

  • It assumes the conclusion. “Neuroplasticity” is a black box, an inference, not a magical wand. It involves mechanisms we do not understand and have simply inferred. But we do know the brain is maximally plastic in the fetal period, so if neuroplasticity applies to adults, then it applies maximally to fetuses.
  • No one knows how much time or what stimuli are needed for neuroplastic mechanisms to occur in a fetus or an adult, but we do know the fetus is developing rapidly in a rich sensory environment. Time and stimuli are ad hoc objections that apply to both if they apply to either. 
  • If subcortical structures and slivers of cortex enable consciousness and even increased pain, then the cortex was never a prerequisite.

A cause for stewardship

Clinicians increasingly know what pain theorists are stumbling toward: cortical necessity is not only irrelevant but also seems to be false. An immature cortex, then, is no reason to deny fetal pain. It is actually reason to err on the side of caution, honing to our universal standard of human rights that protects our own species from the very beginning.


If you appreciate our work and would like to help, one of the most effective ways to do so is to become a monthly donor. You can also give a one-time donation here or volunteer with us here.

WAYA speaking up in pro-choice spaces

We asked, you answered: How do you speak up in pro-choice spaces?

Part of Secular Pro-Life’s mission is making space for non-traditional pro-lifers. Speaking against abortion as a human rights violation is not a religious belief, nor is having a religion a prerequisite for being anti-abortion. Still, non-traditional pro-lifers, especially atheists, may feel overwhelmed at the thought of speaking up about their views in pro-choice circles.

Taking this dilemma to social media, SPL asked followers:

Jacob LeBlanc: If you have goodwill built up with your friends and you have moral certainty in your beliefs, then it’s usually not a problem to have different views.

Nora Ludden: Don’t try to get to the bottom of everything in one conversation. Try to stay emotionally regulated. A calm tone of voice goes a long way. Look for places where you agree and point them out. No name calling or ascribing motive. Ask lots of questions, particularly about points where you disagree. Listen.

@SoloParaLeer11: 1. Always rely on scientific evidence. They only have opinions. 2. Be prepared for insults. Since they cannot beat science, they will start offending personally.

Ann Marie: Car or water bottle (or both) bumper sticker. Keep it subtle (not like I did) and they will ask questions… Trust me!

[Note: You can get SPL stickers here!]

John Dube: I would think if his or her atheism were well known, that would be advantageous in mitigating the common “don’t push your religion on others” objection.

I tend to start gradually with issues we may be able to agree on:

Women should not be pressured or coerced.

The mother’s life should be a priority.

There should be robust support for the expectant mother, newborn child, and needs for several years after birth.

Protecting human life is important [and] we would want to be careful about how we define personhood.

Tim Fennell: As a pro-life atheist, I have no need to explain my opinions although I do offer a simple explanation if asked—I don’t know when human life begins & see no good in ending one without reasonable cause which, for me, does not include personal convenience.

Sara FG: Stick with the science and experts. If even liberal Harvard Med can acknowledge abortion ends a life, it shouldn’t be so difficult for everyone else.

[Note: While this connection is not always so simply made, you can learn more about how a majority of experts agree that human life starts at conception over here.]

Angela Swanson: Ease in. I am not an atheist but am in secular circles, so I like to broach the subject as if I’m the devil’s advocate, or share basic scientific facts like, “Yeah a fetus has its own unique DNA from the mother.” Pepper in some science and it will be hard to argue against in person unless someone in the group takes it very personally.

@ChozangNoyb: Be prepared to lose her friends. But is worth it – she will gain new ones.

Also, try to focus on the precise points in question, and avoid unnecessarily harsh speech as far as possible.

Barbara Stephen: Be humble, kind, respectful and unassuming. Listen to understand. If they value and respect you as a human being they will welcome diverse views and appreciate that you’ve made them think and either challenge their ideas or help them find ways to reinforce them. If they are bigoted jerks they will drop you like a hot potato and you’ll have to find new friends. Which is frustrating but also brings clarity about the sorts of humans you want to associate with, which can be very freeing.

Did any of these comments make you think of your own story? Learn how to share it with our free, self-paced Storytelling Symposium. 

Are you a pro-life atheist or agnostic? We’d love to feature your perspective. Fill out our interview survey.


If you appreciate our work and would like to help, one of the most effective ways to do so is to become a monthly donor. You can also give a one-time donation here or volunteer with us here.

Later Abortion at 33 Weeks - alexander-krivitskiy-KtmF96NBO0Q-unsplash

“33 weeks pregnant and feeling like I made the wrong decision”

[This article is a transcript of “’33 weeks pregnant and feeling like I made the wrong decision‘” courtesy of volunteer Ben Tomlin. If you’re interested in volunteering to transcribe more of our content, please complete our volunteer survey.]

This video is also available on TikTok.

A woman posts in the abortion subreddit saying that she’s 33 weeks pregnant. She initially was actually excited about being pregnant, and she went to a regular OB. While she was there, she said, “Lo and behold, a mini human—arms, legs, a head. It was such a clear picture of a baby.”

She was excited about it until around 15 weeks pregnant. She started to feel not so excited.

Now, at 33 weeks pregnant, she says, “I’m just weeks away from giving birth, and as awful as I feel about it, my mind keeps floating back to the thought of, ‘I wish I had gotten an abortion.’” Then she goes on to express her depression, her concern, and her fears about the pregnancy.

And then, very helpfully, one of the mods for the abortion subreddit says, “If you do want to get an abortion, you can still do that. Is that something you’d like to learn more about?”

And the mod is right. There are not only places in the country where it’s legal to abort at any stage in pregnancy, but there are also places with clinics that will do it for no medical reason.

You can find quite a few accounts like this on the abortion subreddit, and not just women thinking about how they wish they had gotten an abortion, but women getting the specific details and the tens of thousands of dollars to get abortions this late, and women coming back afterward to talk about their experiences getting abortions this late. Some of them talk about how they just didn’t realize how brutally hard it would be. Others have been talking not about how hard it was, but just about how they got through it.

And if your response to all this is, “Reddit’s not a source. Maybe all these different accounts are just making it up for whatever reason,” that’s fine. We list a bunch of sources here, including peer-reviewed academic sources, including interviews of abortion providers talking about performing later abortions for no medical reason.

The information is out there. If you don’t want to look at it, that’s on you.


If you appreciate our work and would like to help, one of the most effective ways to do so is to become a monthly donor. You can also give a one-time donation here or volunteer with us here.