Secular Pro-Life
  • Home
  • About
    • Meet The Team
    • Mission and Vision
    • Stances
      • Abortion
      • Religion
      • Contraception
      • The Rape Exception
  • Content
    • Index
    • Blog
    • Myths
    • Research
      • Abortion Law and Abortion Rates
      • Abortion Law and Pregnancy Rates
      • Later Abortion
      • Embryonic Hearts
      • Abortion Views and Gender
    • Collections
      • For the biology textbook tells me so
      • Fixed that meme for you
      • They can hear you
      • Parents can hear you
      • Our children’s heartbeats
      • Becoming Pro-Life
    • Publications
      • Overview Brochure
      • Why Secular People Should Care
    • Store
  • Contact
  • Get Involved
    • Volunteer Opportunities
    • Donor Opportunities
    • Why support SPL?
  • Donate
  • Menu Menu

Florida Lawsuit Seeks Release of Pregnant Prisoner, Unborn Child

March 1, 2023/in Legislation, laws, and court cases, Uncategorized /by Kelsey Hazzard

Florida inmate Natalia Harrell (pictured) recently petitioned to have her unborn child — and, consequently, herself — released from jail. So far, her legal effort has been unsuccessful.

Initially, this struck me as being a bit like a physically immobile person complaining about house arrest. The child’s immediate environment will be the womb regardless, so what’s the point? Was this a pro-abortion “gotcha” suit to undermine fetal personhood? I acknowledge the personhood of unborn children, and not just in the context of abortion. Nevertheless, as a Florida lawyer, I was skeptical about the merits of the case. The fact that Harrell is charged with second-degree murder gave me further cause for concern; if released, would she be a threat to other human lives?

But there’s another wrinkle: Harrell claims that she and her baby are not receiving adequate prenatal care in custody. Given the awful experiences of other pregnant inmates throughout the United States, that claim is not difficult for me to believe. The Miami-Dade County Corrections Department, for its part, argues that it is trying to offer prenatal care but that Harrell has refused.

The case made its way to Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal. Appellate courts do not resolve factual disputes, and apparently the trial court had not addressed the prenatal care issue. The Third District therefore sent the case back to the trial court for further proceedings. Judge Monica Gordo wrote a concurring opinion which recognized the unborn child’s standing to bring the lawsuit and explored various rights that unborn Floridians enjoy, while concluding that freedom from otherwise lawful incarceration is not among those rights.

The baby is already eight months old. My educated guess is that he or she will be born before the trial court issues a decision, making the case moot.

[Photo credit: Miami-Dade County]

Related Posts

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
  • Link to Instagram
https://i0.wp.com/secularprolife.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/harrell.jpg?fit=576%2C720&ssl=1 720 576 Kelsey Hazzard https://secularprolife.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/SecularProlife2.png Kelsey Hazzard2023-03-01 04:30:002023-03-01 05:27:30Florida Lawsuit Seeks Release of Pregnant Prisoner, Unborn Child

Follow via Email

* indicates required

Categories

  • Ableism
  • Administrative
  • Adoption and Foster Care
  • Biology
  • Bodily Rights
  • en español
  • Late-Term Abortion
  • Legislation, laws, and court cases
  • Medication Abortion
  • Miscarriage & Pregnancy Loss
  • Personhood
  • Philosophy
  • Pro-Life Demographics
  • Rape Exception
  • Religion
  • Research
  • SPL Emails
  • Uncategorized
  • We Asked You Answered
  • Your Stories

Archive

As the national conversation on abortion intensifies, it’s more important than ever that we demonstrate that anyone can–and everyone should–oppose abortion. Thanks to you, we are working to change minds, transform our culture, and protect our prenatal children. Every donation supports our ability to provide nonsectarian, nonpartisan arguments against abortion. Please donate today.

DONATE
© Copyright 2023 Secular Pro-Life. All rights reserved. Website Design by TandarichGroup

Related Posts

ABC sobre la personalidad fetal y la conciencia Women say they grieve but don’t regret abortion. Is that a contradict...
Scroll to top