I am pro-life because...

[Simon JM]

I hardly think someone looses their right to live because they are unhealthy or unlucky enough to be conceived by a rapist.

Don't you think that given the choice in an emergency ward with limited resources and between two people where one will survive and the other will die in a short time regardless, that we should use the resources on the life that will continue?

Secondly we are under no obligation to give organs or blood even to our children, therefore there is no obligation for a rape victim to do so. When everyone is forced to do so things change.

[Cde. ☭]

I hardly think someone looses their right to live because they are unhealthy or unlucky enough to be conceived by a rapist.

Don't you think that given the choice in an emergency ward with limited resources and between two people where one will survive and the other will die in a short time regardless, that we should use the resources on the life that will continue?

Secondly we are under no obligation to give organs or blood even to our children, therefore there is no obligation for a rape victim to do so. When everyone is forced to do so things change.

First, we aren't talking about that. We're talking about killing them if they're unhealthy, when both the mother and baby can survive.

Secondly, if a woman refuses to breastfeed her children when there is no alternative food supply, we can jail her for neglect.

But neither of these address abortion. People like to pretend abortion is some sort of passive act when it isn't.